Books on nationalism

Canada and the Canadian Question

AuthorGoldwin Smith
First published1891
ThemeBritain, Empire and the Anglo-American world

Summary

Goldwin Smith, a British-born historian living in Toronto, argued that Canada's geography, economy and English-French division worked against it becoming a single, viable nation, and that its natural destiny was union with the United States. The book was highly controversial and is a classic statement of continentalism.

Key ideas

Why it matters

A historical debate about whether a multinational state can become a nation — Canada answered by surviving.

Background and context

Smith had been Regius Professor of Modern History at Oxford and taught at Cornell before settling in Toronto, where he became one of the most prominent and contrarian commentators in Canadian public life. The book appeared in 1891, the year of a federal election fought largely over trade with the United States, in which Prime Minister John A. Macdonald campaigned on loyalty to Britain against his rivals' proposal for free trade with the Americans. Smith's case for continental union was rejected by most Canadians, but his questions about whether a country with two founding language communities, scattered across a vast territory, could hold together have echoed through Canadian debates ever since, including those about Quebec.

Who should read it

Read Canada and the Canadian Question if you are interested in Canadian history, federalism or how multinational states hold together. It is a primary source, so it suits readers who want to engage with a historical argument directly.

Related guides and terms

For background, see Nation vs. state, History of the nation state, What is a nation state. Key terms: citizenship, multinational state, nation.

Listed in Lindybook's nationalism collection.

More books on britain, empire and the anglo-american world

See all 28 books on nationalism →