Books on nationalism
Nationalism
| Author | Elie Kedourie |
|---|---|
| First published | 1960 |
| Theme | Theories of nationalism |
Summary
Elie Kedourie's short, fiercely critical study opens by declaring that nationalism is "a doctrine invented in Europe at the beginning of the nineteenth century." He locates its roots in philosophy — Kant's idea of the self-determining will, transformed by Fichte and the German Romantics into the notion that nations are natural divisions of humanity with a right to their own state. Kedourie argues that this doctrine, pursued by intellectuals and activists, has produced instability and violence rather than freedom.
Key ideas
- Nationalism is an intellectual doctrine with a specific European origin.
- It grew out of Kant's self-determination and German Romantic philosophy.
- Applying it to mixed populations breeds conflict.
Why it matters
It is the classic sceptical, conservative counterpoint to sympathetic accounts of national self-determination.
Background and context
Kedourie was born in Baghdad and spent most of his career at the London School of Economics, where he also founded the journal Middle Eastern Studies. His experience of the Middle East, where European ideas of the nation were applied to deeply mixed societies, informs the book's pessimism. It provoked an important reply from his LSE colleague Ernest Gellner, who argued that nationalism was not the product of a mistaken philosophy but a response to the social needs of industrial society, which requires a shared, standardised high culture. That disagreement between nationalism as an idea and nationalism as a sociological necessity has framed the field ever since. Kedourie's book went through several editions and remains a standard text.
Who should read it
Read Nationalism if you want a short, intellectually demanding critique of nationalism from a conservative liberal perspective, or want to understand the history-of-ideas side of the debate. Read it alongside a modernist account such as Anderson or Hobsbawm to see the contrast.
Related guides and terms
For background, see Nationalism explained, Nation vs. state, What is a nation state. Key terms: nation, nationalism, civic nationalism, ethnic nationalism.
More books on theories of nationalism
- Imagined Communities — Benedict Anderson
- Nations and Nationalism since 1780 — Eric J. Hobsbawm
- The Invention of Tradition — Eric J. Hobsbawm and Terence Ranger (eds.)
- Notes on Nationalism — George Orwell